Best use of the dull brown color palette.
Best Special Edition schwag.
Best clone of a more successful game.
Game most likely to cause physical injuries.
Best Anti-Climax! Alan Wake was my most recent game that had an enigmatic cut scene instead of a final boss fight, but I know I've heard there were worse examples this year.
Most improbably-shaped sword
Best Japanese character name
Best Easter egg
Least aerodynamic spaceship
Best attempt to explain an impossible plot twist through "science"
Best mini-game with actual replay value
Most random celebrity voice-cameo
Most entertaining bug/glitch
Least tiresome Zombie-themed DLC
Best place where they obviously went cheap/ ran out of
money
Worst ending that was obvious from the start of the game
Best enemies whom you felt kinda-sorta guilty about shooting in the face. (Fiends are people, too...)
Best use of a small burrowing mammal.
Most badass facial hair of any game character.
Most personally unpleasant main character who is not Kratos.
Best Special Edition schwag.
Best clone of a more successful game.
Game most likely to cause physical injuries.
-Most explosiony car crash.
-Most creepily-obsessive video game review commenter? (probably Graham)
-Least comprehensible plotline.
Least Annoying Game to Watch Others Play
Worst Voice Acting
Best Japanese character name
Best Easter egg
Least aerodynamic spaceship
Best attempt to explain an impossible plot twist through "science"
Best mini-game with actual replay value
Most random celebrity voice-cameo
Most entertaining bug/glitch
Least tiresome Zombie-themed DLC