Comments

1
Firmly in favor of studying/implementing reparations. My basic thought is a 30-year blitz of investment in education, career retraining, capital improvements in black neighborhoods, preference/subsidy to minority-owned businesses for that and other work, and free in-state college tuition over that period.

Further, I propose we obtain all funds required for the project by raising the property tax of Blabby and Todd Mecklem.
2
Give money to people who were never slaves by forcibly stealing it from people who never owned them. Great plan.
3
It's been pointed out that since the Fed is already printing a shitload of money to buy bonds (which is a good thing!) it could instead print a shitload of money and give it to people who were never slaves but nonetheless suffered from constant theft and discrimination and terrorism since the abolition of slavery.
4
@ Spindles, it's called "representative democracy," not robbery.

Also, if it helps, think of it more as an investment than straight redistribution. Think how many middle class jobs the various projects and their administration would generate for people (of all races), and then consider how those workers and their middle and upper class children will contribute to the tax base for generations into the future.
5
@Spindles: Thanks for proving that you clearly did not read the referenced article.
6
An investment is something you do voluntarily. Coercing someone to give you money, and if you don't you ultimately get black clad guy's with machine guns kicking down your door, is robbery. Even if you wear good guy badges and fancy hats.

Say, isn't our "representative democracy" kind of the reason why slavery was allowed to exist in the first place?
7
@Spindles, I don't know why I'm encouraging it, but I'm morbidly curious about your "argument."

Please describe a viable system of governing 300 million people that operates fiscally on the "pay only what you feel like" model.
8
So are they going to go track down the ancestors of the tribes in Western Africa that traditionally took slaves during combat and decided to trade them to the Portuguese and other Europeans for a profit?

Furthermore, does this mean I should keep burning churches until the Roman Catholic church coughs up coin for disrupting the way of life of my pagan ancestors?

Let's just make a compromise and give them a couple of casinos on unoccupied pieces of land outside small vacation towns.
9
It's called Voluntaryism. It's an age old political philosophy based on the application of the non-aggression principle (the non-initiation of force) and that all forms of human association should be voluntary. It's become a whole lot more popular lately, thanks to just how blatant the over-reach of the state has become.

Would it be practical tomorrow? Probably not, considering how ingrained the state has become into every facet of human interaction. But it's a more moral proposition than one that encourages the extortion of one party to provide resources to another on behalf of an action neither party had any involvement with.

I'll tell you what, the American institution of slavery couldn't have been upheld for as long as it did without the heavy subsidization of the government - providing the manpower and cost necessary to round up any slave who tried to escape the plantation - as even the Northern States did well into the Civil War.
10
So does it require 100% agreement to levy taxes or pass laws of any kind? How are laws enforced, if not ultimately by coercion? What happens if people commit violent crimes?

What if the children of Fantasyland's unified front of voluntarists decide that some of the taxes and laws their parents ratified are dumb and they don't particularly want to pay or follow them, but they also don't particularly want to leave Fantasyland or otherwise give up the many benefits of Fantasyland citizenship?
11
"It's become a whole lot more popular lately, thanks to just how blatant the over-reach of the state has become."

I'd love to see your sources on that.
12
While living in Germany, I always felt bad for the youth there, having to live with the sins of their grandparents over WW2 and the slaughter of Jews.
I'll be damned if I am made to feel responsible, morally or finacially, for being born white here.
I find this whole discussion, at this point in time, laughable - at best.
Ironic it is happening at a time when our President is black too.
I don't know how folks promoting this can do so with a straight face.
13
Further, Coates appealing to all of us, hat in hand, for a handout, is something I find deeply shameful in him.

I'm glad that our President, who I am a big supporter of, has never pandered in such a lowly way.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.