During tough economic times, small-town business owner Matthew Peyton (Ryan O'Quinn) struggles with his desire for financial success and the responsibility of funding the annual Christmas pageant. Matthew's popularity also declines when his desperate decisions start to anger his fellow citizens. When Peyton meets Clarence, a joyful boy who believes in miracles, he must make a choice: do what's best for himself or give faith a chance by opening his heart to help his new friend and the community.