Apathy or Discrimination? 

A Homeless Man Is Beaten in the Street, But Police Don't Pursue the Perpetrators

news5.maggy.jpg

Illustration by Scott Mcpherson

ON WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 21, I saw a homeless man brutally attacked by a half-dozen young men. Thomas Lundahl was thrown against the entrance to the Portland Outdoor Store and punched several times before the men ran off.

Several people, myself included, placed 911 calls during the incident, and within minutes three squad cars were on scene at SW 3rd and Oak. I listened as Lundahl, the victim of the attack, told officers that he was on the corner distributing free postcards with drawings he'd done. He spent most nights under a bridge, he said. When asked how the attack started, Lundahl said he tried to intervene when the group of men attempted to steal a woman's iPod.

When the officer asked Lundahl if he wanted to press charges, he declined, even when told that another officer had stopped a group of men that may have been involved in the attack.

When I described what I saw to Mary Wheat, public information officer for the Portland Police Bureau, she told me it's standard to ask victims if they wish to prosecute in cases like this.

"The victim has to want to press charges," Wheat says of this case. Without a victim, "the district attorney can't take the case because there's no one to represent."

There are exceptions to that rule. Domestic violence cases are pursued regardless if the victim goes along with it or not. Same with cases in which a child is the victim. But despite their level of vulnerability, Wheat says the homeless don't fall under the same umbrella.

"We have to be very careful about the manpower that goes into a case when someone doesn't even want to prosecute," Wheat says.

The homeless are particularly vulnerable to assaults like the one I witnessed. More than 40 percent of Portland's homeless have sustained concussions from being attacked while sleeping. Nationally, there were 106 violent acts perpetrated against the homeless in 2008, according to the National Coalition for the Homeless. Twenty-seven attacks were fatal. In the Portland area, there were five recorded attacks against the homeless last year.

Tracking the attacks is made difficult by the fact that many homeless people don't have a phones or addresses. That not only inhibits initially reporting attacks, but also makes it difficult for officers to follow up on investigations, says Israel Bayer, director of Street Roots.

"We have heard that there are increasing attacks on homeless people," said Sally Erickson, homelessness project coordinator with the City of Portland. "The best thing we can hope for is for everyone to have a safe place to sleep at night."

Bayer says because of the difficulties in prosecuting crimes against the homeless, the police and those on the streets have developed a sense of apathy. The homeless may feel like it's useless to report violence, and police don't want to get into cases based entirely on hearsay.

But that's a mindset Wheat doesn't agree with.

"We deal with vulnerable people every day," Wheat says. "We can't force them to sign a complaint. We can't force them to come to trial."

When asked if the homeless should be a protected class like children or domestic violence victims, Wheat said that's not up to the police.

"That's a question for lawmakers," she says.

Comments (9) RSS

Showing 1-5 of 9

Add a comment | All comments »

The homeless man may have had a resentment toward police from past treatment, fear of retaliation or past legal troubles he didn't want a defense attorney bringing up in court. It might have been something as simple as being embarrassed he was beat up.
It was his choice not to press charges. To bad his fears stopped him from holding the perpetrators accountable, but it was good of him to stop the punks from stealing the iPod.

Still Portland has the lowest per capita violent crime rate of any metropolitan area in this country.

Posted by Dan Newth on October 29, 2009 at 12:35 PM | Report this comment

Dan,
great response to a really nicely done article (great job Sean). The only thing I would add is that although Portland's overall violent crimes rate is low, our violent crimes rate against people who are homeless is high... really high... that five violent acts listed in the article puts us behind one city, New York City. and ahead of pretty much everyone else in the nation.
there are ways to fix this though, one that comes immediately to mind is to pass a law for the city, making violent crimes against a person based on their housing status a "hate crime". many cities, including both Seattle and New York have done this already.
thanks
Patrick

(Hate Crimes PDF) http://www.nationalhomeless.org/publicatio…
(laws passed) http://www.nationalhomeless.org/publicatio…

Posted by Patrick Nolen on October 29, 2009 at 5:27 PM | Report this comment

my mistake, that should read "Seattle and Los Angeles". my apologies.

Posted by Patrick Nolen on October 29, 2009 at 5:38 PM | Report this comment

Yea, because somebody who is too lazy, drunk or high to keep a job should be listed as a protected class.

Posted by Matt D. on October 29, 2009 at 7:23 PM | Report this comment

"But Police Don't Pursue the Perpetrators," What a bunch of shit. You said right in your article that the Police actually caught the suspects. I know, I am shocked too, that they weren't too busy sitting at Starbucks and actually caught the bad guys. I love bashing on the cops too, but let's place the blame on where it should be- Lundahl for not pressing charges.

Posted by Sean the man on October 29, 2009 at 7:46 PM | Report this comment

Add a comment

From the Archives

  • A Matter of Opinion?

    County picks Chip Shields for North/Northeast Portland state Senate seat in contentious race.
    • Oct 1, 2009
  • Painting the Town Red

    Chasse protestor charged with felony after splattering red paint at city hall.
    • Sep 24, 2009
  • More»

Author Archives

Most Commented On

  • Testing Craigslist

    Undercover with Portland's housing discrimination police.
    • Nov 5, 2009
  • Black and Blue

    Gresham's only black cop resigns post, alleging discrimination.
    • Nov 5, 2009
  • More»

Top Viewed Stories

  • Bad Apple Reputation

    A new lawsuit hangs over the cop involved in the death of James Chasse.
    • Jan 29, 2009
  • Pay Back

    A freelance writer drags PDX Magazine to court over back pay.
    • Aug 28, 2008
  • More»

/images/adoftheweek.gif

ad of the day

Need Scooter Service?
We sell and repair scooters, and have a full service department specializing in Chinese brand scooters; we work on all brands of scooters, however.go


post an ad

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC

605 NE 21st Ave
Portland, OR 97232

Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Production Guidelines | Terms of Use