I Love Television™ 

Fargo Pros, Fargo Cons

ilovetv-570x300.jpg

Dear World: I love the Coen brothers so much I want to squeeze their faces off!!! I love Blood Simple, I love O Brother, Where Art Thou?, I love Raising Arizona, I love... [this is where you leave the room for 10 minutes to get a sandwich and then return to realize I didn't know you were gone]... for Old Men, I love Inside Llewyn Davis, I love True Grit... and I especially love their hilariously brutal murder comedy Fargo. Which is why I have both "squeeees" of joy, and "hmmmms" of concern about the upcoming TV adaptation of Fargo (debuting Tues April 15, 10 pm, FX).

The original movie was a beautiful buffet of blood and laffs set in the brutal winter wonderland of Minnesota. Struggling car salesman Jerry Lundegaard (William H. Macy) hires two criminals to kidnap his wife so he can keep half of the ransom money, but of course everything goes awry, and the crooks end up killing a state trooper, innocent witnesses, and later, disposing of a body by... umm... dumping it in a wood chipper. (I mentioned this was a comedy, right?)

Anyway, the very pregnant Police Chief Marge Gunderson (Frances McDormand) follows a hilarious trail—lined with thick-accented Minnesotans—to bring both kidnappers and car salesman to justice. It's funny, bloody, and (surprisingly) charming and sweet. Kind of like Our Town crossed with Taxi Driver.

Awesome, right? Yes! HOWEVER! Reboots of anything should be gazed upon with the greatest of suspicion, and even with an excellent pedigree, this new televised incarnation of Fargo comes with a litany of pros and cons. TO WIT:

PRO: Fargo (the TV series) is executive produced by Joel and Ethan Coen, but.... CON: They aren't really involved otherwise. This could be problematic, since the Coens' style has so far been impossible to imitate without coming off as cartoonish.

Also CON: It doesn't star William H. Macy and Frances McDormand, but.... PRO: It has a kick-ass cast including Billy Bob Thornton, Bob Odenkirk, aaaand (SQUEEEEE!!!) Martin Freeman (AKA Sherlock's boyfriend Watson)! Again... SQUEEEE!!!

Also PRO: Instead of trying to remake the movie version, they've created a new story that shares the same bone-chilling Minnesota landscape. Billy Bob plays traveling hit man Lorne Malvo who takes an interest in mild-mannered life insurance salesman Lester Nygaard (Freeman). When the sheepish Lester makes an off-hand comment about an evil local bully, assassin Lorne decides to even things up in the best way he knows how: murrrrrderrrrr.

Enter Deputies Molly Solverson (Allison Tolman) and Bill Oswalt (Odenkirk), who work the case with help from a cast of colorful local Minnesotans who say things like "dern tootin'" and "ya betcha"... but! CON: There's a real danger of portraying these quaint townsfolk as a joke, instead of realistic, nice people with funny accents and a dark undercurrent running through their souls. (See the Coen brothers' version for more on this, or consult your local library.)

The only way to find out if this Fargo will be a hallelujah hit or a fury-causing imitation is to watch it this Tuesday on FX! PRO: It's on FX! (Home of Justified, The Americans, and Louie!) CON: I don't have time for another great FX show!

This Week on Television

WEDNESDAY, APRIL 9

10:00 FX THE AMERICANS

Phillip tries to hack into the government's ARPANET—the original internet! (Pro tip: Their password is their birthday!)

10:30 FXX ALI G: REZURECTION

Borat attends an English rowing event—but doesn't everybody in the world know him by now?

THURSDAY, APRIL 10

8:00 NBC COMMUNITY

Subway plans to buy Greendale and replace it with a Subway University... which is a step up, right?

10:00 ABC SCANDAL

President Fitz considers Olivia's reelection advice while ramming his tongue down her throat.

FRIDAY, APRIL 11

10:00 NBC HANNIBAL

Jack's star pupil is alive! (Until Hannibal finds out, of course.)

SATURDAY, APRIL 12

9:00 SYFY BERMUDA TENTACLES—Movie

(2014) The president's plane goes down in the ocean and he's attacked by a giant octopus! WHAT ARE THE ODDS.

11:30 NBC SATURDAY NIGHT LIVE

Hosted by the reliably funny Seth Rogen!

SUNDAY, APRIL 13

9:00 MTV MTV MOVIE AWARDS

Hosted by the even more reliably funny Conan O'Brien!

10:00 AMC MAD MEN

Season premiere! Season seven opens with Don finding a new friend. (Let me guess... a female friend.)

MONDAY, APRIL 14

8:00 SYFY METAL HURLANT CHRONICLES

Debut! Warriors battle their robot overlords in this series based on the classic sci-fi mag Heavy Metal.

TUESDAY, APRIL 15

8:00 PBS

PIONEERS OF TELEVISION

Season premiere! An overview of stand-up comics who went on to sitcom glory.

10:00 FX FARGO

Debut! A hitman manipulates an insurance salesman to help him with murrrrrderrrrrrr.

Comments (0)

Subscribe to this thread:

Comments are closed.

From the Archives

More by Wm.™ Steven Humphrey

Most Commented On

Top Viewed Stories

All contents © Index Newspapers, LLC

115 SW Ash St. Suite 600
Portland, OR 97204

Contact Info | Privacy Policy | Production Guidelines | Terms of Use | Takedown Policy