One of these things is not like the other.

Answer (of sorts) after the jump.

Okay, follow my logic. I'm pretty sure that the makers of these "spooky" tombstones meant to write John Wayne Gacy in that second one. Why, you ask? Because just to the left of these tombstones is this electric chair. See!

John Wayne would love this chair?!

So the correct answer is:

Maybe this is River Phoenixs serial-killer doppelganger?