News Sep 13, 2012 at 4:00 am

Enough with the Fluoride Circus

Comments

1
Commissioners Saltzman and Fritz would deserve credit only if they had offered an amendment requiring further outreach to the public, similar to the meetings used to get public input for the Portland Plan, or even better, requiring a public referendum before implementation.

They didn't do that, and so failed to stand apart from the City Hall oligarchy. I mean, two lame ducks plus three lame incumbents -- is this any way to run a city?

The commissioners talked themselves blue in the face on the subject of dental hygiene. But they said barely a word about the biggest issue: Democracy.
2
We elect the Mayor and Commisioners to make these decisions and cast these votes, and even though it took a long time, this is local government at its' best.
Finally.
3
Apparently there are smart and well intentioned fluoridation foes who aren't paranoid? Maybe I've been too hard on them...
4
"misinterpreted studies" studies huh?

National Research Council: http://www.actionpa.org/fluoride/nrc/NRC-2…

--"Children in high fluoride areas had significantly lower IQ scores than those who lived in low fluoride areas,"
--"The results suggest that fluoride may be a developmental neurotoxicant that affects brain development at exposures much below those that can cause toxicity in adults."

Reading is hard. Looking information that isn't spoon fed to you by the lobbying organization behind the Everyone Deserves Healthy Teeth campaign is hard.

One thing I haven't misinterpreted is the giant banner for the fluoride lobby that's been hanging over your blog for weeks$$$


5
Wow Denis. I guess you and the Portland Mercury now think the hipster thing to do is go the way of the Oregonian & Willamette Week and have an obvious bias when 'reporting the news.' Next time we see each other, and I know we will, I'll look forward to you telling me to my face that my saying 'white guilt' was circus-like. Sometimes the truth is tough to face but the excuse of 'feeling bad' for low income and children of color was used as an excuce over and over at the fluoridation hearing by Leonard, Fish, and Adams. That bad feeling the council has ignores the source of dental disparities and throws at these vulnerable children the cheapest form of a band-aid that comes from phosphate processing. It's an insult to minority and low in-income residents to supposedly 'help' kids by giving them, and all of Portland, Tigard, Tualitin, and Gresham, a diluted industrial by-product.

I'm not angry at you Denis, but I am disappointed that you chose sarcasm and trying to sound cool, over journalistic integrity. I hope in the future you will find ways to report to your readers rather than pander to certain audiences.

http://lulac.org/advocacy/resolutions/2011…

http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/ci…
6
Well said VC. Dennis is my favorite writer for the Merc. However, his commentary in this article was uncharacteristically bias for him.

And one thing that also stuck out for me was the mention of extra security. I've attended public hearings at CH before, and never noticed security at all - other than a guy in a nice jacket directing people where to go. So much security now, security everywhere. Why do i not feel secure???
7
You would do yourself and your readers a greater service by doing your homework. You might want to start with medical writer Joel Griffiths and then check out Christopher Bryson. You will discover, as other investigative journalists have, that the fluoride issue is a huge cover-up that goes all the way back to workers on the Manhattan Project and involves players like Robert A. Kehoe, director of Kettering Labs. Dr. Kehoe was the leading defender in the US of the "safety" of leaded gasoline. He also defended fluoride on behalf of DuPont, Alcoa and U.S. Steel, companies who have all faced lawsuits for industrial fluoride pollution. The attorneys for these corporations, which included Reynolds Metals and Monsanto, formed the Fluorine Lawyers Committee. Those corporations funded the fluoride research at Kettering which included human experiments on African American lab workers in the years following World War II. A brilliant Harvard toxicologist, Phillis Mullenix, finally published her fluoride research in 1994. After testing and re-testing over 500 rats at fluoride intake levels equivalent to those of high water drinkers such as athletes and dialysis patients, she discovered that fluoride is a neurotoxin. Pregnant rats who drank the fluoridated water gave birth to hyperactive babies and those offspring gave birth to babies exhibiting mental retardation. She was promptly fired from her position at Forsyth Labs and her research which represented a major breakthrough was immediately defunded.

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.