Transportation Jul 19, 2011 at 2:46 pm

TriMet Crackdown!

Sarah Mirk
Back to article

Comments

1
"And fare inspectors don't cover their own costs."

I think you're failing to take into account that a visible, reliable fare inspector presence probably acts to deter many of those who might otherwise risk getting on without buying a fare.
Commenty Colin on July 19, 2011 at 3:07 PM Report this
2
A fare inspector makes $67,000 per year??? I'm doing something wrong.
jim on July 19, 2011 at 3:17 PM Mercury Staff
3
$67,000 is complete insanity.
on July 19, 2011 at 3:29 PM Report this
4
I guess I'm going to look into being a Fare Inspector.
Graham on July 19, 2011 at 3:45 PM Report this
5
"A fare inspector makes $67,000 per year??? I'm doing something wrong. "

Sounds like a lot, especially if your making 10 bucks an hour. But 67k after taxes and social security and union dues etc etc is not as great as it sounds.

Macfarlane makes $244k, as a matter of fact there are plenty of people who make much more than 67k.

Which ones are most valuable to the public interest?

http://www.box.net/shared/cvndf2i7hi
Al M on July 19, 2011 at 4:01 PM Report this
6
Al, as someone that makes less than $67,000 a year after taxes and so on, it really is as great as it sounds. Checking fares requires no education, or particularly special abilities. Why can't they find people who will do it for $10/hr?
Anony Mouse on July 19, 2011 at 4:19 PM Report this
7
I wonder if they'd be more likely to issue citations if they were $50 instead of $175.
Paul Cone on July 19, 2011 at 4:29 PM Report this
8
btw I agree that $67K is total insanity if that's the salary, and not Trimet's TOTAL cost per year for the employee, e.g. including all benefits, training costs, equipment etc.
Commenty Colin on July 19, 2011 at 4:29 PM Report this
9
Wow, our taxes are helping pay a fare inspector 67k? See if I ever vote pro-TriMet again.
Broseph Goebbels on July 19, 2011 at 6:59 PM Report this
10
Thanks for the shout, Sarah! For what it's worth, the $91.50 is based on the amount TriMet gets after splitting its $175 fine with the other agencies who have to push some of the paper in this situation. (County and state, I believe.)

Point is, TriMet really has few tools to force people to pay if they don't want to. It'll be interesting to see if they can find some.
Michael, Portland Afoot on July 19, 2011 at 8:15 PM Report this
11
It sounds like TriMet needs to renegotiate the pay for inspectors or start using non-union inspectors. As others have noted, that is a pretty excessive salary for an unskilled position (well, there's conflict management skills, but that's not so rare or hard to train someone in). Plenty of people would be willing and able to perform this job at $10-$20/hour, thus in this case the union is acting as a barrier to entry for other working adults.

The other issue is the low percentage of citations. Imagine if 75% of parking tickets were just warnings! The proper way to do this is to issue citations to everyone, with the knowledge that many people (especially those who can't really afford it) will not pay them. Most people will pay and the amount raised would be way more than TriMet is getting now. Just like with parking tickets, they can choose to be lenient on people who just have a couple outstanding fines, but aggressively go after those "scofflaws" with mounting numbers of tickets.

The other option is to just push the passes as much as possible and move to an honor system. Most people will still pay because it is the right thing to do. If fare enforcement is actually costing more than it is bringing in, it either needs to be reformed or done away with--otherwise what is the point?
on July 19, 2011 at 8:58 PM Report this
12
It sounds like TriMet needs to renegotiate the pay for inspectors or start using non-union inspectors. As others have noted, that is a pretty excessive salary for an unskilled position (well, there's conflict management skills, but that's not so rare or hard to train someone in). Plenty of people would be willing and able to perform this job at $10-$20/hour, thus in this case the union is acting as a barrier to entry for other working adults.

The other issue is the low percentage of citations. Imagine if 75% of parking tickets were just warnings! The proper way to do this is to issue citations to everyone, with the knowledge that many people (especially those who can't really afford it) will not pay them. Most people will pay and the amount raised would be way more than TriMet is getting now. Just like with parking tickets, they can choose to be lenient on people who just have a couple outstanding fines, but aggressively go after those "scofflaws" with mounting numbers of tickets.

The other option is to just push the passes as much as possible and move to an honor system. Most people will still pay because it is the right thing to do. If fare enforcement is actually costing more than it is bringing in, it either needs to be reformed or done away with--otherwise what is the point?
zefwagner on July 19, 2011 at 9:02 PM Report this
13
What is the job situation for the security guards you see at, for example, the Green/Yellow terminus at PSU under? There's always personnel there, and they look trains over inside to make sure everyone got off and stuff. From what I can gather it doesn't seem they're TriMet supervisors but I could be mistaken. $400K a year is 6 guys at $67,000. If we paid $12/hr it would pay for more like 16 dedicated fare inspectors! Why the heck does a fare inspector need to know how to drive a bus or train?
Anony Mouse on July 19, 2011 at 9:36 PM Report this
14
WOW! $67k is a great salary for standing around, checking tickets, and going to court. An entry level Portland police officer only makes $43k and will take FOUR years to reach $67k salary level (PDF).

Comment #1 is correct, keeping troublemakers off the system is extremely important and maintains the value of transit. Also, don't you feel like an idiot paying to ride the MAX when there's no chance of fare enforcement?
on July 20, 2011 at 8:01 AM Report this
15
The best thing I've ever heard a Tri-Met bus driver say was (just before some fare inspectors got on the bus): "Here come the spare infectors."
dimitrir on July 20, 2011 at 2:42 PM Report this
16
$175 is another tax on the poor who struggle to afford public transportation. Still, I wouldn't begrudge the people who have good paying public sector union jobs that are getting harder to find. Is everyone expected to be non-union and paid minimum wage these days? Where does the downward spiral end?
on July 20, 2011 at 9:27 PM Report this

Please wait...

Comments are closed.

Commenting on this item is available only to members of the site. You can sign in here or create an account here.


Add a comment
Preview
Posted by (your name here)

By posting this comment, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use.

More In Transportation

Public Backlash Killed the Last I-5 Bridge Replacement Plan. In the New Version, Critics Say Little Has Changed.
STREET VIEW: Soho House and Portland's Disappearing Public Spaces
Despite Funding Windfalls, the Future of the Rose Quarter I-5 Project Remains Uncertain
A $1.7 Million Federal Grant Will Jumpstart Portland's Public Electric Vehicle Charging Infrastructure
New Plan Seeks to Help Lower Southeast Portland “Rise”
Portland, Prepare For a Six-Week MAX Disruption

Editors' Picks

Hundreds of Critical Portland Operations Workers on Strike After Mediation Fails
Updated: Commissioners' Proposal Could Throw a Wrench in Voter-Approved Charter Reform Plan
POP QUIZ PDX: Sassy-Ass Trivia About Gas Pumpin', Dame Lillard, and TOTAL RECALL (of the Portland City Council, That Is)
Monkey Business, Monica Lewinsky, Protein Thefts, and Being Cool and Slutty
THE TRASH REPORT: Spotify Thinks I'm Basic but Gay, Paris Isn't Just a DJ, and George Santos is Laughing All the Way to Unlimited OnlyFans
Sassy-Pants Trivia About Our Terrible City Council, Dame's Latest Accomplishment, and... Did I Mention Actor Sam Elliott Is a Close Personal Friend?
Portland Mercury
is a proud member of the media network
Masthead Ad Info & Rates Jobs at Portland Mercury Contact Privacy Policy Terms of Use Takedown Policy
Support Portland Mercury
All contents © Index Newspapers LLC
PO Box 86208, Portland, OR 97286