Okay, this meeting of the Lost Discussion Group will hereby come to order! First order of business: Who’s slipping Ambien into the writers’ Ovaltine? Last night’s episode “The Substitute” was chock full o’ Locke—but other than the occasional burst of energy here and there, was it at all worth it? LET’S TALK ABOUT IT!

As per usual, I’ll post some spoiler-y discussion starters after the jump, but feel free to gab about anything Lost-related you’d like. Uno, dos, quatro… DISCUSS!

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz... SNRK! KAFF! Zzzzzzzzzz...
  • “Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzz… SNRK! KAFF! Zzzzzzzzzz…”

1) Actually I loved the part when the Smoke Monster was walking around inside Locke’s body, and tripped and fell on his stupid fat face.

2) And remember that scene where the smoke monster is whipping around the compound peeking in windows and trying to catch Sawyer in his shit-stained underpants? WOULDN’T THAT HAVE BEEN A GREAT PLACE FOR THE BENNY HILL THEME SONG???

3) Dear Jacob: If you really want to live in a shitty cave (ever heard of IKEA? or maybe a dry erase board, instead of writing names on the ceiling?), that’s fine; but building three of the most disjointed, flimsy ladders in the history of the world is NOT going to help you attract candidates to your home! GAWD!

4) Poor Peg Bundy! Am I right??

5) Were you as groany and unsurprised as I was when the teacher in the high school lounge turned out to be Ben? What would’ve been great if he had turned around and it was the polar bear wearing glasses and a suit!

6) How did this episode rate in comparison to the first couple of eps? Do you feel hopeful for the rest of the season, or think the show is going to resemble the underside of Sawyer’s underpants?

Bang bang, choo-choo train, let me see you shake that thang. Wm. Steven Humphrey is the editor-in-chief of the Portland Mercury and has held the job since 2000. (So don’t get any funny ideas.)

12 replies on “Let’s Talk <i>Lost!</i>, or “Clumsy, Clumsy Smoke Monster””

  1. I am very into the idea of candidates beings crossed off a list, and each of them assigned a number. You can see several names of dead characters that have been crossed out. I also like how Sawyer knows that it’s fake Locke and doesn’t give shit. Same island, same shit. Whats up with baby Jacob and these “rules” he speaks of?

    And I am loving the freaked out Richard Alpert!

  2. 1) I’m wondering if the kid is the spirit of the island that Jacob is protecting. I don’t think it’s young Jacob, or reincarnated Jacob, nor do I think Jacob possessed Sayid. But the kid really pissed off Smokey, and I’m thinking that has to do with Smokey’s anger at being stuck on that island. Jacob is the Protector. Smokey is the Antagonist. The Kid is the Spirit. If we’re gonna get all weird/religious with this, I like the trinity of spirits we have in this theory.

    2) Smokey was pulling some slight of hand with his explanation to Sawyer. Obviously, the numbers correspond to candidates. But there’s a reason they chose the flashbacks they chose. If Jacob touches you, you’re a candidate. That’s pretty obvious, even if we didn’t see a number for Kate, or a number for Sayid. We saw Sayid’s name, too, but Smokey never called it out. He skipped 2 numbers when he was rattling off the list of candidates to Sawyer, and after 4 names, just went to “And last but not least,” before making his pitch to Sawyer.

    I’m thinking the twist to this particular mystery is that there’s a 7th number. And it’s Kate. As much as that annoys me. I’m also pretty certain the list of candidates is the list of names inside the Ankh that Dogen smashed over his knee. Those names correspond with the names scrawled on the cave, I’m pretty sure.

    I’m also sure that the whole point of this season, and the series, is gonna come down to the two timelines converging or becoming cognizant of each other, and the choice being this: You can let Smokey get what he wants, which will likely preserve this peaceful, happy, winky smiley alternate timeline where Rose is fine with her fate, Locke is fine with his fate, Ben is a cranky/funny history teacher, etc. etc. or they will stop the evil that Smokey represents, knowing that by doing so, all that happiness goes completely out the window.

    Pretty simple choice, but I think that’s why they’re stacking the deck so hard with the alt-storyline: Why stop Smokey when you know that somewhere, in some universe, you will be as happy as you can be should he live? You know what the choice SHOULD be (stop evil) but it’s a hell of a lot harder to make that choice when things feel so right in the alternative.

    Plus – I’m pretty sure Richard was right in more than a few ways with his warning to Sawyer – I don’t think that cave is Jacob’s at all. It’s Smokey’s. He’s keeping track of the people Jacob is bringing there as candidates. And he’s crossing their names off once he’s dealt with them/corrupted them. Now that Jacob’s dead, he can’t bring any new candidates. And if he can get one of them to leave the island with him, to kick a hole in that circle of ash, if you will, then he gets what he wants. Ilana said he’s recruiting, and I think she’s right. Now whether Richard meant that he’ll kill the candidates, he’ll kill that alternate reality where everyone’s happy, or he’ll kill every version of those characters in every reality, Dark-Tower style, I dunno.

    I also think Hurley is the new Richard – the only person on the island who can talk to Jacob. Which is why Jacob touched him and made him a candidate. Hurley is Jacob’s insurance policy for when he finally is killed via Smokey’s loophole: What better way to exert your influence via the only person on the island who can see and converse with dead people. (Miles probably has something to do with this, too.)

  3. Sorry, Fatboy! Our commenting system crapped the bed, forcing you to be brilliant twice. I deleted the first one, and now everything is awesome again.

    BACK TO LOST! So do you think the “numbers” written by all the names in Jacob’s cave correspond to Hurley’s lottery numbers? Or is this an obvious observation to everyone else in the world?

  4. I appreciate Fatty’s in-depth analysis but I just don’t think the show is paced well enough to see any of those possibilities through to fruition, let alone resolve the stories of all the other main characters and sub-plots in the remaining episodes.

    Call me shallow but here’s what happened in the episode: Black Smoke Locke takes poopy-pants Sawyer to Jacob’s cave. Island Locke is still dead Locke. U.S. Locke is married to Leela, gets fired, sees Hurley, sees Claire, sees Ben, calls Jack’s office and yells at girls to run laps. Oh, and Sun is told she may get to see Jin again at the temple (oooh, my crotch is bulging with anticipation)!

    All this could’ve taken place in one segment. Go back and watch any episode from past seasons and compare how much more dense and interesting and progressive they were to the current bunch. All those flashback and back-story eps? Genius. Even last season’s new characters (Farraday, for ex.) found fast footholds into story arcs. Now it’s a lot of slow-paced blah and meh.
    At least there was no Kate in this ep!

  5. Easily the best episode of the season… but that wasn’t a high benchmark to reach. Two-part episode 1 = B-. Episode 2 = C-. Last night = B+.

    My favorite scene last night was when Rev. Jackson rode his bicycle to the police brutality/bike lane rally/protest. Wait, where am I?

    But seriously, all this focus on Jacob/Smokey this season, and the ultimate good/evil smackdown (where this season appears to be headed), makes me wonder how things like the Dharma Initiave (among other things) really fit in. The Others are Jacob disciples/descendents, so that ties in, but if the eternal, centuries old battle between Jacob and Smokey is ultimately the only thing that matters, then all those seasons focused on things like Dharma and their scientific endeavors now seem pretty trivial and relatively pointless. Jacob has spent years identifying potential candidates to take his place if anything should happen to him, Smokey has spent years trying to kill Jacob and now must kill these other potential successors, and ultimately, one side will win in the finale.

    And yes, Humpty, the numbers written on the cave walls next to the Oceanic names correspond with the Hurley/hatch/everything numbers.

  6. I’m finding it hard to even muster up the motivation to comment about this episode. Sadly, this comment thread is more exciting and interesting than the season’s episodes so far. At this rate, is ANYTHING interesting going to happen, or are we all still going to be holding our (figurative) dicks by the finale? I grow weary. Please, let all of this Lost watching over the years not be for nothing. Time to break out the razzle dazzle, with a quickness!

  7. Wm.: The Numbers in Jacob’s(?) cave are indeed Hurley’s lottery numbers, but clearly they’re also more. For reference, the Numbers and their corresponding names were: 4-Locke, 8-Reyes, 15-Ford, 16-Jarrah, 23-Shephard, 42-Kwon.

    JA: I think that the significance of the Numbers is too great to dismiss Dharma as trivial or pointless. Remember that they put the Numbers on the hatch, and that the Numbers are what Desmond and others type into the machine. So clearly Dharma is not completely removed from the rest of the storyline. I believe the significance of Dharma is twofold. Firstly, I believe Smokey brought them to the island, to free him, destroy the island, harness its power, whatever. Secondly, they’re part of the show’s greater dialectical storytelling framework, that being Science vs. Faith. Jack vs. Locke, Dharma vs. the Others, Linus vs. Widmore, etc.

    Fatboy: I agree that the cave is probably Smokey’s. I also agree with your guess as to the eventual outcome of the series. For a while I was wondering if there’d be a Dark Tower-esque ending, but that’s looking very unlikely now that we’re getting into S6.

  8. Richard Alpert= LSD scientist. It’s going to come into play…I know it. maybe the numbers are different drug combos? Whoever doesn’t see the smoke monster when tripping wins.

Comments are closed.