Firstly, all this “Gretchen’s a bitch” nonsense is an overreaction. So last night’s episode split the designers into two giant teams, and because she was the only person coming up with ideas, and the only one taking charge of the situation, with her teammates following her around like baby ducks saying, “Yes Gretchen, please Gretchen,” that makes her a bitch? No. It makes the rest of her teammates indecisive weaklings. I don’t even think it was even edited to make her seem manipulative. It portrayed a lot of other people sitting on their hands and sucking and not having any opinions being all too willing to follow the one person with some get up and go… Not to say that what happened on the runway was great. The “Team Luxe” collection was a major blah, and the speeches made on the runway were weird, but only because they were a retaliation against playing the TV-land game of cut-throat bullshit that is Project Runway. The judges just don’t like being talked back to, and they certainly don’t like being asked to be “mindful” or to be told how to make decisions confidently. It’s their TV show so they are always un-touchably right. Plus if they were making judgments “mindfully” (seriously, though, stop saying that) then their whole catty house of cards comes down on them. Go back and watch the last couple chapters again. Gretchen talks positively about what they tried to do with the collaborative process, but at no pint does she say anything positive about the end result of the collection other than it being “cohesive.” It’s Heidi, Michael, and Nina who turn around and say, inventively, “Oh but you loved it before [they’re making that up] and now you’re backpedaling.” They keep harping on this fantasy until everyone believes it, but it’s not there in the footage. There is plenty of manipulation happening on this show, but it wasn’t coming from Gretchen. Anyhow, here’s what she had to say:

Oh yeah, and Michael is incompetent. Spoiler after the break.

Gretchen is safe, but they made her sit in the hot seat in the final two. A.J. seemed unsurprised to bite the dust. And Casanova won! His hilarious couch-flopping diva moment boded ill, but he pulled it off. I’m glad, I’m not ready to see him go. More couch flopping and odd elfin slippers, please. Lovely guest judge Georgina Chapman on his look:

Here’s to next week.

Marjorie Skinner is the Portland Mercury's Managing Editor, author of the weekly Sold Out column chronicling the area's independent fashion and retail industry, and a frequent contributor to the film and...

7 replies on “<i>Project Runway</i> Wrap Up: IT’S AN OUTRAGE!”

  1. ugh. i continue to be disappointed with the changes that have filtered into this show the last season or two. there’s less honest critique, and more theater being manufactured by the judges and, most sadly, Tim Gunn. it feels like it’s devolving into more standard “reality TV” fare.

    Gretchen definitely has the skillz to make the top three, but as a designer (in a different medium) I have to say that she would annoy the shit out of me in a similar situation. agree that it makes great TV, though. lots of people love to hate.

  2. First of all, the designers are judged on their overall process of creating garments. And Gretchen throughout the entire day was very impressed with her work. Her work is boring, uninspired and ordinary. Yes, she is good tv. But as a loyal PR watcher, I could care less about her personality. She is rude, self-centered and full of it. Just because I live in Portland does not mean I believe she is the better designer – Leannimal won a couple years ago and we do not need a copycat. Like Michael said, “Fashion is a tough business” – and Gretchen is neither scrappy nor innovative in her design or personality. There is a reason she makes fashion in Portland and not in NY. Tim Gunn was right on the money about who she is.

  3. I really really wanted Gretchen to go home.

    I started the season thinking she was talented and worth rooting for but her behavior and reliance on leggings is getting old. She seems so entitled and bossy but she views herself as a “nice person”. My impression is that she is a silver spoon tall thin white women whose true colors are coming out now that she is not on top. This is all my skewed impression based on what the director chooses to put in the show but her behavior has definitely been unkind.

    I was really happy for Casanova and Micheal C when they won even though I know they won’t win the season. The hate coming from Gretchen and the others was so mean and so typical of trashy reality tv (which I think PR has avoided in the past seasons).

    Also did anyone notice that tacky upskirt shot of Ivy the editors threw in?

  4. “Also did anyone notice that tacky upskirt shot of Ivy the editors threw in?”

    hard to miss since they showed it twice.

    the quality of this show is really going downhill with the producer’s yen for “drama”. it’s really bumming me out.

  5. Thanks sansan1, that is good news.

    I guess I’m the only person who liked Team Luxe’s collection. I thought Gretchen was right on that it looked both more cohesive and wearable than the other group’s. I also thought AJ’s shirt-dress wasn’t bad (though the shiny material it was made with was a weird choice).

    Gretchen’s runway moment was majorly awkward. She DID backpedal and she DID come on way too strong about how proud they all were and then how sad they all were. I don’t think she’s wrong that Michael sucks, though. And I stand by Marjorie’s statement that, more than Gretchen looking bitchy, the rest of her team came across as all too happy to give Gretchen the reins at every turn. It’s easy to criticize someone’s driving from the backseat. I’d be rooting for Gretchen even if she wasn’t from Portland because I think she has knocked every challenge out of the park.

    Oh, and Mondo. I like Mondo.

  6. Ugh, just saw the episode. I can’t help but feel that all of this new drama is contrived in an effort by the producers to amp up ratings (to which end they are, apparently, succeeding). Marjorie is right that they could not even edit the material to make Gretchen appear sufficiently manipulative or bossy. All I saw was someone stepping up to take initiative, and rather than feeling “bullied,” her teammates seemed grateful. She was hardly “Hitler” as one other contestant, the thoroughly forgettable April, was somehow allowed to call her on television.

    The collection was a wash. Terrible, frankly. And Gretchen has embarrassing logorrhea on the runway. But that doesn’t excuse Tim Gunn’s wretchedly feigned righteous anger, for which he should really apologize. Incredibly poor taste. Is it worth having more than 4 million viewers if your show ceases to be about fashion and instead becomes clichรฉ reality tv drama dressed with Garnier infomercials? Sadly, probably.

Comments are closed.