Across Oregon, a historic number of candidates of color are running for elected officeâand many have a solid chance of winning on Tuesday. But as two Multnomah County races show, with more diverse candidates come new, important questions around the role of race in political campaignsâand how a candidate of colorâs past experiences might be viewed differently than a white candidateâs.
For Rima Ghandour, an Arab American immigrant and candidate in an unusually competitive Multnomah County judge race, that issue is apparent in how her white opponent, Adrian Brown, represents Ghandourâs relevant experience in a campaign mailer. Specifically, the mailer suggests that where Brown has extensive âcourt reformâ experience, Ghandour has ânone.â
What made the mailer upsetting to Ghandour, who owns an insurance law firm, is that she has a track record of providing pro-bono services and volunteer work meant to make the criminal justice system fairer for people of color.
In political campaigns, and especially political advertisements, itâs common for politicians to highlight their own record while casting doubt on their opponentâsâbut Ghandour says Brownâs mailer goes beyond that. She adds that the negative impact of this ad was exacerbated by Brownâs issuing an Arabic-translated version of the mailer, in which Ghandourâs record on court reform is described with a word meaning ânothingâ or âno one.â
âIt was really disheartening,â Ghandour says about the mailer, which she initially saw in Arabic, her first language. âTo have that be referred to as ânothingâ and ânobodyââso who is the ânobodyâ?â she said. âThe community Iâm helping? Or me?â
Ghandourâs experience includes providing pro-bono work for immigrants whoâve been granted temporary residency under the DREAM Act, and organizing a group of attorneys and translators to go to airports in Portland and Seattle in 2017 to assist travelers after Donald Trump instated a travel ban against people from seven Muslim-majority countries. As a board member and past president of the Multnomah County Bar Association, Ghandour presented to judges in Multnomah County about the experience of Muslim people in Americaâs criminal justice system, and organized panels around transgender rights, disability awareness, and the experiences of houseless people.
âWhen the travel ban happened, Rima was one of the first lawyers at Sea-Tac [Seattleâs airport] on the ground, providing pro-bono legal work,â says Sahar Muranovic, a David Douglas School Board member who supports Ghandourâs campaign. âSheâs very known and connected in the immigrant community, in the BIPOC community. The mailer, where it says [ânoneâ], felt a little inappropriate.â
In the mailer, Brown highlighted her own record as a civil rights attorney who worked for the US Department of Justice (DOJ) under the Obama Administration, during which she won a settlement against the Portland Police Bureau (PPB) that required PPB to improve the way it treated people experiencing mental illness. That record might be more easily recognizable as court reform work than Ghandourâs pro-bono and volunteer work. But Ghandour says the omission of her work is reminiscent of the way people of color and immigrants are often expected to perform sometimes intangible diversity work in their industries without recognition. It also brought her back to other experiences sheâs had in her career, when colleagues underestimated her abilities or condescendingly told her she speaks English well.
âThere are all examples of things that are not traditionally seen,â she says. âBut they are important to the community, and important to trying to move the needle toward inclusion and acceptance of people of color in the legal profession.â
Brown tells the Mercury that she thought it was important to translate her mailer into nine different languages to ensure accessibility, and that she paid a professional translation service for the Arabic mailer.
In an interview with the Mercury, Brown defended the mailerâs comparison between her and Ghandourâs records. The American Bar Association does not allow judicial candidates to campaign on political issues, she points out, meaning all she can run on is her experience.
âThis has never been about degrading Rimaâs experience as an immigrant,â Brown says. âThis is a competitive judicial race that is about a difference between someone whoâs chosen public service and civil rights, and someone whoâs chosen private defense and the business of practicing law.â
âI really saw this race as not identity, but as experience,â she adds. âRimaâs experience as a woman of color is a fact, and it doesnât trump the fact that Iâm a civil rights attorney with a record thatâs unique.â
Musse Olol, the chairman of the Somali American Council of Oregon, sits on the steering committee of Brownâs campaign. He first met her when she was working on civil rights issues with the DOJ.
âSheâs created this bridgeâa bridge that actually has maintained the last 10 years,â Olol says. âSomebody asked me, âWhy donât you support the Muslim candidate?â and I said âIâm supporting the candidate that I think is most beneficial to the community. And that is Adrian to me.ââ
In Gresham, another campaign mailer is causing a stir in the mayoral campaignâthough rather than omitting a candidateâs experience, this one is under scrutiny for the experience it highlights.
Eddy Morales, a current member of the Gresham City Council, is running for mayor among a crowded field of mayoral candidates. A recent PAC-funded campaign mailer attacks Moralesâ record of criminal charges, most of which are now over 15 years old.
âA lifetime of criminal activity⌠and now wants to be your mayor? [sic]â the mailer reads.
Morales has been candid about his brushes with the criminal justice system when he was a teenager and young adult, and even referenced them when testifying in favor of youth criminal justice reform before the Oregon Legislature. The one recent charge listed, for driving under the influence in 2017, was dropped before it went to trial. The mailer also lists infractions Moralesâ business incurred for not paying taxes on time.
For Morales, the focus on his criminal recordâand use of a mug shotâequate to a racist dog whistle.
âMy teenage past are things that Iâve really been open about,â Morales says. âI donât know that, had I not been a person of color or LGBTQ+, they wouldâve taken that tack⌠Itâs unfortunate someone would try to use my past to shame me, and shame other people in our community who have things in their past.â
But the part of the mailer that irks Morales the most isnât the focus on his own recordâitâs that it attacks Morales for supporting antifascist and Black Lives Matter activists. A photo of Morales with a Black Lives Matter sign is featured, as is the word âAntifaâ stylized in large, bold letters.
âThey started attacking me for standing up for Black lives,â Morales says.
The PAC behind the mailer is Oregon Progressives for Accountability. Its director, Patrick Sheehan, is a real estate agent and former Republican member of the Oregon House of Representatives. Sheehan dismisses Moralesâ issues with the mailer in an email to the Mercury.
âWith the content of the mailer laser-focused on Moralesâ history of documented criminal activity âcomplete with citations and links to the raw police reportsâitâs an obvious manipulation by his campaign to draw such a bizarre and dishonest conclusion,â he says. âWe pulled a [Black Lives Matter] photo off the internet that was selected because it was suitable for print resolution, thatâs all.â
But for Morales, the mailer points to anxieties over a changing political reality in Gresham.
âFor the last 20 years, our city has been run by a really small group of conservative Republicans who are all members of our Chamber of Commerce,â he says. âI think this year, weâre on the cusp of changing that⌠This small group of people who have really enriched themselves over the last 20 years are afraid of losing control.â