This Frank Rich piece in New York Magazine back in March is worth a second reading...
Thereâs no way liberals can counter these votersâ blind faith in a huckster whoâs sold them this snake oil. The notion that they can be won over by some sort of new New Deal â âdomestic programs that would benefit everyone (like national health insurance),â as Mark Lilla puts it â is wishful thinking. These voters are so adamantly opposed to government programs that in some cases they refuse to accept the fact that aid they already receive comes from Washington â witness the âKeep Government Out of My Medicare!â placards at the early tea-party protests.
Perhaps itâs a smarter idea to just let the GOP own these intractable voters. Liberals looking for a way to empathize with conservatives should endorse the core conservative belief in the importance of personal responsibility. Let Trumpâs white working-class base take responsibility for its own votes â or in some cases failure to vote â and live with the electionâs consequences. If, as polls tell us, many voters who vilify Obamacare havenât yet figured out that itâs another name for the Affordable Care Act thatâs benefiting them â or if they do know and still want the Trump alternative â then let them reap the consequences for voting against their own interests. That they will sabotage other needy Americans along with them is unavoidable in any case now â at least until voters stage an intervention in an election to come.
Trump voters should also be reminded that the elite of the party theyâve put in power is as dismissive of them as Democratic elites can be condescending. âForget your cheap theatrical Bruce Springsteen crap,â Kevin Williamson wrote of the white working class in National Review. âThe truth about these dysfunctional, downscale communities is that they deserve to die. Economically, they are negative assets. Morally, they are indefensible.â He was only saying in public what other Republicans like Mitt Romney say about the â47 percentâ in private when they think only well-heeled donors are listening. Besides, if National Review says that their towns deserve to die, who are Democrats to stand in the way of Trump voters who used their ballots to commit assisted suicide?
So hold the empathy and hold on to the anger. If Trump delivers on his promises to the âpoorly educatedâ despite all indications to the contrary, then good for them. Once again, all the Trump naysayers will be proved wrong. But if his administration crashes into an iceberg, leaving his base trapped in Americaâs steerage with no lifeboats, those who survive may at last be ready to burst out of their own bubble and listen to an alternative. Or not: Maybe, like Hochschildâs new friends in Louisianaâs oil country, theyâll keep voting against their own interests until the industrial poisons left unregulated by their favored politicians finish them off altogether. Either way, the best course for Democrats may be to respect their right to choose.








