Russell J Young

Larissa FastHorse’s The Thanksgiving Play, now playing at Artists Repertory Theatre, is a beautiful skewering of sanctimonious, upper middle-class white guilt. It’s a joke at the expense of comfortably privileged people who only began to care about politics after the 2016 election and stopped by the inauguration. It’s a committed, well-crafted satire, right down to the Seventh Generation disinfecting wipes, culturally inappropriate smudging, and references to Burning Man. That’d be enough to sustain this brisk, 90-minute play—please can all plays be 90 minutes—but there’s much more at work here.

October is Dine the Couve - 3 for $25 menus
Experience the bounty of northwest flavor with special menus at Clark County restaurants all month.

The Thanksgiving Play’s very existence is a jab at the theater world’s lack of meaningful diversity—FastHorse’s previous plays, which were focused on Native American characters, weren’t getting reproduced due to theaters’ professed casting difficulties. So FastHorse wrote a play that didn’t require Native actors. The characters in The Thanksgiving Play are white, and it’s a true reversal to see white actors deliver lines written by a Native American playwright skewering white culture. It’s pointed and deservedly mocking, and doesn’t let its characters off the hook.

The legacy of racism and oft-ignored genocide at the heart of America’s worst holiday is revealed in all of its terrible glory here, with offensive elementary Thanksgiving skits intercut with the action, as struggling, tunic-clad director Logan (Sarah Lucht) attempts to put together an age-appropriate yet enlightened yet abstract yet accessible Thanksgiving performance for elementary schoolers. She’s joined by her street-performer paramour, Jaxton (Michael O’Connell), an obnoxious new age-y man wearing a culturally appropriated mala, who reminded me of every real obnoxious new age-y man wearing a culturally appropriated mala. They’re assisted—somewhat—by Alicia (Claire Rigsby), a white actress they’ve mistakenly identified as Native American based on her intentionally racially ambiguous headshot, and Caden (Chris Harder), an amateur actor and dramaturg played by Harder with a manic delivery reminiscent of The Good Place’s Jason Mendoza.

Support The Portland Mercury

Russell J Young

The play’s broad silliness—and the actors’ commitment to its absurdity—makes these characters easy to laugh at, and it was a medium-weird experience to hear a room full of Portland theatergoers—mostly white, and mostly, I’d guess, over 40–laugh, essentially, at themselves. Maybe that’s an important exercise, though. It’s easy for well-intentioned liberals of a certain age and character to drown their pretty good values in self-seriousness and sanctimony. (This is, after all, the Pacific Northwest, the center in the Venn diagram between West Coast whiteness and well-intended liberalism.)

Only by laughing at our performative seriousness do we see it’s part of the problem.

Migration Brewing Rooftop at Canvas Now Open!
This 9th floor patio boasts stunning views of the city, three mountains, and Portland’s West Hills.