So I had a LOST inspired nightmare last night in which all the cast members were with me on the island, including a NUDE PATRICK COLEMAN who wouldn’t stop rubbing his large, distended belly. Brrrrrrrr. (He’s not fat in real life, btw.) ANYWAY! Only two new episodes left, you guys, and last night’s offering entitled “Across the Sea” focused entirely on the relationship between Jacob and the “Man in Black,” and explained a poop ton about their VERY WEIRD relationship. There is A LOT to discuss about this one, so let’s get moving! As is my want, I will post some SPOILERISH discussion questions/starters after the jump, so what are we waiting for, ya’ll? LET’S TALK LOST!!

1) First of all, which is the more annoying Alison Janney: the old-timey killer nanny on Lost, or CJ from The West Wing?
2) Did you like the little musical cue that told viewers “Hey, we’re tired of writing subtitles, so we’re gonna speak American now!”?
3) “Team Tow Head” or “Team Bieber”?
4) The Lite Brite cave: Pro or con? (I’M CON, BTW!!)
5) So how does the Lite Brite Cave play into the mythos of the show? So like the cave contains all the goodness in the world, and if it gets out, that’s bad for some reason, and WHAT?
6) Most unintentionally hilarious line of the show: “These men! They are smart! Together we will build a wheel… and hook it up to a system… and THAT is how we will get off the island!”
7) Wow. CJ from the West Wing must be pretty spry to burn down an entire village and kill everyone in it.
8) Actually, I liked this episode, and thought the acting was especially strong—but there were quite a few bullshitty things going on! Give me your overall thoughts, as well as best and worst moments!

I’m never letting Alison Janney “apologize” to me.
This was the worst episode of Lost in a long time. It was like a heavy-metal rock-opera without the music. I was so bored I actually started to miss Kate and Jack.
And when the hell are they going to bring Ben back?
Haley Mills was so ADORABLE in this episode. I’m sad those two didn’t get their parents back together, though.
Transmogrifying into a destructive black smoke thingy won’t ever undo the fact you got beat up by your step-mom.
WORST episode of Lost ever! At least the Nikki & Paolo episode had Lando Calrissian in it!
I liked the episode, it served it’s purpose of giving a bit of back-story. The big reveal seems very old school sci fi…but really? what was it going to be?
I disagree about the acting. You can credit it some of it to young and old Smokey’s actors, but young and older Jacob were pretty flat. I know he’s a good Mama’s boy who doesn’t ask a lot of questions, but man.
I think young and old Jacob are meant to be terribly flat. It reminds me of Star Wars. I’ve always defended the prequels’ terrible acting as being congruent with the original trilogy’s because Luke delivers most of his lines in Episode IV in an odd way similar to young Anakin Skywalker. Seems like a hereditary speech impediment.
I have never trusted Jacob and now I can really see him as a perfect representation of Christianity.
I thought this was a really amazing episode. It answered alot of questions while providing deeper mysteries. I loved seeing MIB’s backstory. He’s “special”, kinda like hurley…hmmm. But it was way too short, they should’ve scattered a few of these episodes throuout this season. And why did they not show the statue or the temple??