So, our friends over at Jezebel have decided to ask the great unaskable question: “If you were to pit pie against cake in a March Madness style tournament bracket type thingy, with winners determined by on-line vote, who would win?”
- Madness!
Yesterday’s first round of voting saw Birthday (seeded #1) conquering Fruitcake (16) and first seed Apple smashing the fourteen seed Grasshopper pie. No-brainers really. But looking at the bracket, I think we may see some upsets. Especially considering cherry pie is a seventh seed contender. I can honestly see cherry going all the way.
Who will take it? I think pie is definitely going to come out on top. This is based on my own experience making both a cake (lemon poppy-seed bundt) and a pie (strawberry rhubarb) last weekend. Pie uber alles.
But that’s just me. Who are you rooting for?
Cake! Carrot Cake – #1!
What kind of fucking asshole put cheesecake on the pie side? Bullshit. This whole thing is dumb now. NEXT!
I could see a carrot cake and cherry pie final.
pink dea took the words right out of my mouth!
Carrot cake FTW!
I’m thinking ice cream cake vs. Apple pie final with ice cream winning because if you don’t like ice cream cake you can take your ass right back to the Soviet Union.
Where’s the hair pie and beefcake?
Coffee Cake or Pound Cake. I’m pretty sure Pound Cake is just baked butter.
No peach pie – WTF?