It's as funny and smart as poo-poo/pee-pee humor can be. It's not the worst thing y'all've published, but Alison is right -- it's nothing to get all high-fivey about.
(And, yes, i'm making the assumption that it's not her, but rather Erik, touting its bestness.)
Needs a poll so we can vote. I vote good but not best. I seem to remember Captain Picard, The Hulk, and Mike Daisy in that spot being some of my favorites.
"Why Does Everybody Assume I Must Have an Immense and Fiercely Powerful Love Log? by a Sexually Inexperienced and Actually Rather Modestly Hung Balrog"
It is the worst thing. Make no mistake. There's already no real need for your fake alternative rag to exist in a town this size. why compound your difficulties by culturally defecating in public? tree killers!
Please wait...
and remember to be decent to everyone all of the time.
(And, yes, i'm making the assumption that it's not her, but rather Erik, touting its bestness.)