When Stacie Love started going to therapy after the birth of her second child, she began grappling with the facts of her marriage for the first time: In 1995, when she was 15, she met Brett Fischer, her English teacher at Gresham’s Centennial High School. In her early adulthood, they got married.

They hadn’t started dating until after she’d graduated, but as Love took a harder look at her life, she began to understand that she’d been groomed as a teenager, a dynamic reinforced by the culture of Centennial High School, and a lack of accountability for educator sexual misconduct. 

“It was almost a compliment to be picked by one of the teachers,” she says on the new independently produced reported podcast Not Just a Terrible Story. “There were many teachers that were flirting with students, having inappropriate relationships with the students.”

Now in her 40s, Love’s excavation of this painful personal history is the focus of Not Just a Terrible Story, created by Seattle independent journalists Sydney Gladu and Katy Klein. Their thesis—that in far too many school settings, and at Centennial High School in particular, educator sexual misconduct is rampant and enabled by insufficient school policies—is illustrated over six thoughtfully crafted episodes, as Gladu and Klein examine Fischer and Love’s hasty marriage as part of a darker, more wide-ranging pattern of behavior, and a culture of complicity that enabled it. It also delves into a similar investigation focused on Jeff Stanek, who coached Centennial High School’s girls’ basketball team and was investigated by the school after student athletes alleged that he’d tried to groom them.

Stories of educator sexual misconduct—and abuse in general—can be hard to talk about. They can be difficult to report, both logistically and emotionally—sometimes people close to the story don’t want to talk, earning trust takes time and sensitivity, sometimes you have to triangulate if you’re speaking to a vulnerable source, and vicarious trauma can be engulfing even for reporters who think about awful things every day.

Even when that trust and sensitivity is evident, as it is in Not Just a Terrible Story’s humane and careful framing, these stories can also be challenging to place when it comes time for publication. Producing Not Just a Terrible Story independently without the major institutional backing of a larger newsroom or podcast network, said Gladu, was “less of a decision and more of just ‘We want this story out there,’ and at a certain point, you’ve exhausted every other option.” She doubted whether Love’s story would have been told in a typical newsroom because “it’s not the type of story that always gets told.”

She’s right. Though journalistic approaches to stories of sexual misconduct have improved exponentially in terms of sensitivity and accuracy in the years since the Me Too Movement, there is still a long way to go. As a reporter who has covered issues like this for years, I was disappointed by the sense of surprise that emerged, for example, in the wake of the Cornell 7 case, which, while horrifying, felt all too familiar given the ubiquity of sexual misconduct. That sense of shock made it painfully clear that the lessons of Me Too, and the national student movement against campus sexual assault that began over a decade ago, hadn’t endured.

But if we must learn the same lessons over and over again—sexual misconduct is ubiquitous, the carceral state rarely offers resolution for anyone involved, the manosphere is making it worse—reporting like Gladu and Klein’s is instructive in showing listeners what these crimes and inappropriate behaviors can actually look like, and how even quite subtle behaviors, in a student-teacher dynamic, can signal grooming. It doesn’t always take the form of a sensational high-profile court case like the investigation into Mary Kay Letourneau that filled tabloids in the 1990s. It can be something as simple as a teacher who seems to be overly familiar with his students, and whose behavior may never be prosecuted or addressed at all beyond the walls of the high school where it happens, normalized and reinforced by a community who chooses to support a likeable teacher over a student with inconvenient information about him.

What’s shocking about Not Just a Terrible Story isn’t really what happened between Fischer and Love—abuse of power comes as no surprise—but that it was such an open secret in their community, something many other people were aware of and didn’t seem to question. Demonstrating that complicity is one of the podcast’s strongest moments, and it’s something that was important to Gladu. 

“[As an adult]it’s your job to protect every young person, and I think that’s another theme that really comes through,” said Gladu. “This type of abuse, it might happen at the hands of one perpetrator, but it is the community accepting it that has allowed it to flourish for so long.”

Not Just a Terrible Story is available on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. For more information, visit terriblestory.substack.com.