The days grow shorter, the nights grow longer, and the time of Oscar-contender cry cinema is upon us. Among them Club Kid, written and directed by Jordan Firstman: a tv writer who parlayed pandemic-era internet celebrity into playing an internet celebrity named “Jordan Firstman” who was definitely really sucking cock in Sebastián Silva’s black comedy Rotting in the Sun (2023). 

Firstman also stars in Club Kid as Peter, a New York City club promoter who unexpectedly finds himself saddled with Arlo (Reggie Absolom), a child that he conceived in a drug-related blackout 10 years earlier. According to what the audience is shown, most of Peter’s job requires traveling from darkened room to darkened room snorting drugs with (and providing drugs to) NYC’s nightlife while oontz oontz oontz music plays in the background. And so the question becomes: In a profession so not conducive to child raising, can this manchild raise an actual child? 

It’s a classic sitcom plot: Set up the situation, wait for the comedy. But the result is pure melodrama. In the film’s press materials, Firstman reports that—after he joined forces with Alex Coco, the producer of Anora (2024)—the two began stripping the script down to the studs, cutting out about 80 percent of the jokes, and weaving in heavier emotional notes, using edgy family melodramas of the 1970s (Kramer vs. Kramer, An Unmarried Woman) as a template. 

Left to Right: Jordan Firstman, Reggie Absolom Credit: A24

Club Kid also pays homage to ’70s gritty cinematography, naturalistic acting, and heavy use of improvisation, but there’s a noticeable absence of the antic, anything-goes quality that those films absorbed from the era’s surrounding culture. Such mash-ups of traditional Hollywood tropes and French New Wave documentary-style filmmaking were made during a window of time when gender roles had hit a level of chaos so high that almost everything felt kind of queer-coded. The old rules were gone. The new rules hadn’t arrived. Everyone was complicated. 

In Club Kid, characters stick to their stereotypes. The nice characters are extremely nice. The mean characters are extremely mean. The helpful characters are extremely helpful. The characters of color are gorgeous and stylish and arrayed around the film in such a way as to make it seem infinitely cooler by proxy. Only Peter is allowed to be complicated and to have a discernible character arc—every other actor revolves around him, like background dancers in a Vegas show. 

Left to Right: Miss Benny, Jordan Firstman Credit: 24

The performances from Firstman and Absolom are good enough that this often doesn’t matter. Arlo feels like an implausibly perfect child, but Absolom convincingly plays him as a traumatized, vulnerable person keeping their real self under wraps in order to navigate a world of unreliable adults. There’s an appealing game-recognize-game dynamic between Arlo and Peter. They both have a talent for, and have made a full-time occupation out of, managing the emotions of those around them.

Still, the realness doesn’t stick. By the time the final credits rolled, Club Kid felt more like a throwback to the films those ’70s family dramas were based on, like a techno reboot of “woman’s film” melodramas like Stella Dallas (1937). 

“The woman’s film” of the ’30s and ’40s focused on romance and family, topics that movie-making studios believed would only apply to women audiences. While such works were often written and directed by gay men, like George Cukor, or immigrants who thought the American dream was a pile of shit, like Douglas Sirk, the subtext and complicated characters found in the genre’s best works were all smushed into the conventional-as-hell Hollywood storytelling framework of their age. 

Club Kid emerges from a similar mold, with its fusion of edgy veneer and iconic Hollywood stereotypes. Like Coco’s Anora—whose hooker-with-a-heart-of-gold protagonist never falters in her love for a doofy baby oligarch and his awful family—this formula may well land Club Kid those Oscar noms. However, that doesn’t make it any less of a bummer for those who have actually experienced the wild diversity of queer family to watch Club Kid fall into the familiar cadence of a big-budget, big-studio picture. The moral of the story was family, and apparently, there’s only one kind.


Club Kid opens at Cinema 21, 616 NW 21st, Fri Nov 20, 122 minutes, cinema21.com, rated R

 HR Smith is a writer and editor. She is exceedingly interested in most things.