Okay, Blogtownie Lost fans and detractors! It’s time to talk Lost, and in particular last night’s episode, “What Kate Does” (which in my opinion is not much of anything except run away from things and look hot). Feel free to discuss what you like, but after the jump I’ll post some spoiler-y discussion starters, just to get the ball rolling. For example: IS KATE, LIKE, THE WORST FUGITIVE ON THE RUN (like ever) OR WHAT??

Kate-Sawyer-Lost_240.jpg

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #1:
Is Kate, like, the worst fugitive on the run or what? Do people in the alternate universe not know that if you steal a cab to escape, you DUMP THAT CAB ASAP?

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #2:
And are alternate universe cops stupid too?
Cops to Claire: Hey, Claire! We saw an escaped murderer escort you into the hospital. Have you seen her?
Claire to cops: Nope.
Cops to Claire: Okay! Thanks!

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #3:
Wait… Jack has a sister? Maybe I’ve been obsessing too much about drunk daddy, but I have no memory of this. You?

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #4:
Another reason to hate Claire: SHE MURDERED MAC FROM IT’S ALWAYS SUNNY IN PHILADELPHIA! Seriously, I was so psyched to see him on the show, and he gets biffed right when he comes off the bench? BOOOOO!!!

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #5:
Also I hate Genghis Khan and all those dicks at the Temple. OH, SURE I’LL GIVE SAYID YOUR PILL WITHOUT KNOWING WHAT’S INSIDE. Because this is like, college.

POSSIBLE DISCUSSION TOPIC #6:
Do you like where this season is going? Yea or Nay?

DISCUSS!!

Bang bang, choo-choo train, let me see you shake that thang. Wm. Steven Humphrey is the editor-in-chief of the Portland Mercury and has held the job since 2000. (So don’t get any funny ideas.)

22 replies on “The Blogtown <i>Lost</i> Discussion Group Will Now Come to Order!”

  1. Alt universe Kate is just like regular Kate; a silly twat. You’re right on the nose about ditching that car. Even Arzt had her license plate, for pete’s sake. What was she thinking, that she would pick up some fairs and make a little dough on the side?

    Topic #3
    Yeah, Jack has a sister. It’s Claire, as has been established over and over again since season two (Claire doesn’t know yet and Jack hasn’t seen her since he found out). You watch this show, right?

    These temple others are ticking me off. Buncha dickweeds. Also, whats up with Ethan using his Dad’s name, Goodspeed, instead of his previously established last name, Rom? Was he evacuated with the rest of the DI during the end of last season, and therefor not an other? Was he always doomed to be a doctor? Does Jack no him in the alt reality? Do they golf together?

    AND WHAT THE FUCK WAS UP WITH WET GHOST WALT IN SEASON 2?????? I WANT ANSWERS ABOUT WALT!!!!!!! WAAAAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLT!!!!!!

  2. Claire is Jack’s sister. She supposedly has been taken over by Abel/Esau/Smoke Monster/Dude from Deadwood.

    Kate is NOT HOT she is probably the most annoying character in the history of TV.

    Everybody in Lost is really stupid, especially the cops.

    Even the bad guys think they’re the good guys, no one wants to admit they’re a bad guy except fake John who just doesn’t give a crap.

    Three episodes in and still nothing much is happening. Not much time left to make this interesting, people!

    Japanese dude selectively speaking in Japanese is less annoying when he just drops the lame contrived convention and speaks English. Dumb idea.

    I’ll have more but that’s it for now.

  3. OKAY! OKAY! JACK’S SISTER IS CLAIRE! Jeez. Can’t a guy smoke a little too much dope in college and occasionally forget a minor TV fact and his mother’s maiden name now and again?

  4. This happens to me every season – First episode or two I think “This show is really fucking stupid” and then I get hooked. Thank god it’s all over this year.

  5. What if these guys at the temple and Jacob are the real bad dudes and the Deadwood guy/Smoke Monster in black and the people getting “claimed” are the good guys? As in maybe “claimed” is more like “saved” ? GAH! What if it’s all just a game played by the “gods” of say, Olympus for example, played at humanity’s expense? What if these jerkoff writers are just making this up as they go along and don’t have any real idea of what they are doing? GAH! WAAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLT!

    p.s. I am so glad Michael is not around anymore because I think he is actually more annoying than Kate. That guy is the worst actor ever.

    p.p.s. I feel like they are still wasting an awful lot of time on this Kate/Sawyer/Jack love triangly thing which in my opinion is by far the least interesting part of the show.

  6. Kate makes some dumb moves, but one could make the argument that she’s the BEST fugitive ever (not only because she’s hot, but because she always gets away – like to an island or something).

    I’m with you on Genghis – but I’ve always disliked the Others. Can’t they just answer a fucking question or two?!?!

    I give the season an “eh” so far.

    And Claire is Jack’s sister (Jesus, they’ll let anyone post on the Interwebs these days)

  7. Dogen and John Lennon guy annoy me! It’s like, if no evidence has been presented to viewers that Sayid is “infected” (he got tortured and was totally hurt by it – how is that “failing” the test?), and they’re barely answering any of Jack’s questions, how are we not going to be baffled and annoyed by their behavior? Everything they are doing at this point makes no sense to us.

    However, I did think those scenes with Dogan and Jack were the best ones of the episode (and maybe Sawyer crying over Juliet, too).

    Kate didn’t do squat!

  8. This was some Season 2 shit. Nothing the characters did for the first 40 minutes made any sense outside of “We need them to act like this for plotting purposes.” These people conspired to revolt, murder, and eventually detonate a nuclear fucking warhead just DAYS previous, after 5 seasons worth of growing as characters. And then they get in the temple and turn into total morons for no other reason than plotting contrivance. It wasn’t until Jack swallowed the pill that anyone began behaving with any sort of character consistency. very highly frustrating episode.

  9. Agree.

    scene: Sawyer’s like, “I wanna bust outta here.” Kate’s all, “No way, man! Do NOT do that.”
    a minute later: Sawyer is shooting a gun around in order to tell everyone he’s leaving.

    Just leave, dude! Don’t shoot a gun first. And where did Kate go? A minute previous she’d been campaigning for you not to leave. I guess she lost the argument, or got distracted?

    And then everyone wants to chase after Sawyer…. why not just let him go? He obviously didn’t care about bringing Kate or Jin with him. And Kate obviously could have done a better job trying keep him at the temple. Just admit, Kate, that he doesn’t want to hang out with you. But no, first she has to chase him down and chat with him before it becomes totally apparent to her that he’s just not that into her.

    Yeah, it was a frustrating episode. Jack doing something crazy at the end was a relief.

    But next week! Oh man, next week…. right guys?

  10. Theory:

    Sayid, Christian and Claire are all on the same side. They’ve been claimed by an entity that uses corpses as hosts. I think the entity is Jacob, and they are members of his Zombie army.

    Evidence that they are not on Locke’s side: so far we know that smokey can take the form of the dead, but he seems to leave the actual corpses alone.

    Evidence that they are on Jacob’s side: if we believe Christian, he speaks for Jacob. Add to that the fact that we haven’t seen Christian/Claire/Sayid’s corpses separate from their zombie selves, suggesting that they have been possessed rather than imitated.

    Jacob is good and Smokey is bad, but the temple others are also bad. They are smokey’s army, not Jacob’s.

    /theory

  11. An interesting thing I read at another website – If you look at the people that Smokey has inhabited as ghosts/spectres/Locke-what-have-you, they’re a) All Dead when he impersonates them and b) all dead WHEN THEY GET TO THE ISLAND.

    That’s a pretty interesting coincidence. Although I couldn’t tell you WHY it’s interesting, just that there could be something to it.

    But seriously – There was no reason for Kate to follow Sawyer, although there was plenty of reason for Jin to leave with Kate. There’s no reason for the Others to be this dick, and there’s no reason for the Losties not to tell the others “We just exploded a nuclear fucking bomb and Jacob is dead and we’re pretty aggro about getting off this rock so how about you guys cut the shit, especially since Jacob just pointed out you need us all. What are you gonna do, kill us?”

    The Losties have the upper hand by a wide margin. As in it’s not even fucking close. The Others need them way more than they need the Others. This is basic leverage that even HURLEY seemed to get in the 1st episode. To write these characters in this episode as rockheaded fucktards too blind to see it is sorta insulting, honestly.

  12. Ok, I was kind of hoping Claire’s ultrasound would show a hideous monstrosity in the making – weren’t they alluding to her baby being evil or something back in the second season? It’s been too long now but I’ve been under the impression she has Damien in there.

    Agree on all counts of the ridiculousness of Kate’s escape – she’d have never even made it out of LAX, let alone LA streets. And Claire, after being kidnapped at gunpoint just sits down right where Kate dropped her off, doesn’t summon help from anyone and is still sitting there half an hour later when Kate comes back for her? Gaaahhhh!

  13. The actors all look tired of their roles. There’s not a single character with any personality. Every single tertiary Dharma initiative/The Others/Les Autres role is as stiff as my dick is NOT whenever Kate comes on the screen. Blech.

    I did like the surprise cameo by Mac from It’s Always Sunny. I was honestly hoping Green Man would show and kick someone in the balls. Nay, kick everyone in the balls.

  14. As far as acting, I think Jacob has been very good this season (and in last season’s finale), as well as Locke. Otherwise, meh to the acting.

  15. Kind of a lame episode, I have to say. It feels like the writers are treading water (like the first half of a couple other seasons), but that sucks since there aren’t really many episodes left!

    Also, the car mechanic that Kate goes to… did we know him? At least I thought it was one of the Others, but I dunno… I didn’t seem to recognize him after awhile.

  16. I’d just like to announce that I, again, have not seen the show, and have no idea what it is about. But I will say that from 8-10 on Tuesday nights I know where Humpy’s mom can be “Found.”

  17. @Fatboy Roberts I disagree. I don’t think that Christian and Smokey are the same. I think that it is Christian/Jacob/Sayid and Smokey/Locke/the guy on the beach at the end of last season who told Jacob he wanted to kill him. It’s not Smokey possessing Christian, imo.

Comments are closed.