Multnomah County and Oregon state election results show that the count of those voting for Harris was less than the number voting for Biden in 2020â41 thousand fewer votes at county (367,249 in â20 and 325,927 this year), with 99,783(!) less at state level. The New York Times has reported that the Democratic vote also weakened in crucial Rust Belt citiesâŚa similar shift then, ultimately dooming Kamalaâs campaign. What caused this lack of enthusiasm for her candidacy? Was it that she didnât articulate enough an agenda resonating with the working/middle class & describe sufficiently how Trump could wreak havoc on our socioeconomic âsafety netâ? Was it that she didnât break with Biden on Gaza, demand a ceasefire, and oppose Bidenâs shipping more arms to Israel? This is Peter Beinartâs argument: âDemocrats Ignored Gaza and Brought Down Their Partyâ (www.nytimes.com/2024/11/07/opinion/democrats-israel-gaza-war.html). These presidential results foreshadow rough times ahead for liberals and progressives, in what will most likely be an uphill battle to gain enthusiasm and ensure electoral victories in key positions. (Also interesting: âMaps Pinpoint Where Democrats Lost Ground Since 2020 in 11 Big Citiesâ: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2024/11/28/us/elections/precinct-city-maps.html)